Why is my second child so different? Constitutional differences in a family and traits that skip a generation
KEY ANSWER
If one of your children is especially hard to understand, it is likely that the child's constitution differs from yours. Children usually take after one parent, but a child can also inherit a grandparent's constitution, skipping a generation. Knowing that the constitution is different lets you adjust things such as meal portions and how you ask about feelings.
Why is one child especially hard to understand?
It is not a matter of good or bad, or of doing well or poorly. In most cases, it is because the parent who is puzzled and the child have different constitutions. The hardest case is when only one child in a family of four differs. If both parents and the first child share a constitution and only the second child is different, both parents may find the second child hard to understand.
What does it mean for a constitution to skip a generation?
Children usually take after their parents, so one parent can understand the child by recalling their own childhood. Occasionally, however, a child is born with a grandparent's constitution. In that case the parents are confused. The easier it is to understand the child who shares their constitution, the harder the other child seems.
What happens in a family when constitutions differ?
Take a hypothetical family in which the parents and the first child have the Cold (寒) constitution and only the second child has the Hot (熱) constitution.
| Situation | Parents and first child (Cold) | Second child (Hot) |
|---|---|---|
| Action | They see badminton on TV, order rackets right away, and go to play the next day | Feels the family is too hasty and impulsive. Needs time to get used to a new sport |
| Meals | Feel full after eating little | The food served feels too little, so the child looks for snacks |
| Conflict | Voice complaints immediately, argue, and make up right away | Holds it in and suffers alone, or lets it build up and explodes. Remembers hurt feelings for a long time |
Each side finds the other frustrating, but it is nobody's fault. It happens because they do not know they are different. Put in extreme terms, having a different constitution is like being a different animal. A deer cannot be expected to understand a seal.
How should I relate to a child with a different constitution?
For the family in the example, the following would help.
- Serve generous meals: prepare everyday meals with the second child in mind.
- Ask about feelings often: if a patient child who does not get angry is simply seen as "well-behaved," accumulated stress may burst out all at once later. Check often for what the child does not say first, and encourage them to express more.
This does not mean something is wrong with the second child. Parents know how to respond to the first child by recalling their own childhood, but that is difficult with a child whose constitution differs, which is why this advice is offered. If the combination of constitutions in a family is different, the advice changes too.
Why should a family learn their constitutions together?
Even when a parent and child share a constitution, there is much to explain, because many people do not clearly know their own constitution or temperament. Knowing your own and your family's constitutions helps you understand one another and decide how to respond to each person.